Search This Blog

01527--Write a note on the eight fallacies.


If we rely on experiences as evidence for our inferences and explanations, we must screen the ways in which we handle those that offer themselves so as to avoid making unwarranted presumptions about them and to avoid exploiting their ambiguity in various tempting ways. Otherwise, we may be guilty of fallacies of presumption and ambiguity in a variety of ways.  Examining them will help us avoid egregious errors in our thinking. Although thinking that commits such fallacies is common, it is always misleading.

I

If we rely on experiences (or anything else for that matter) as evidence for our inferences and explanations, we must screen the ways in which we handle them in order to avoid making unwarranted presumptions about them and equivocating over what they mean.
A. These cautions are also prerequisites for useful inference drawing.
B. When we presume, in one way or another, facts that are not in evidence, and when we play fast and loose with the meanings of our locutions, we are (once again) “not even in the ballpark, much less in the game.”

II

Here are descriptions and examples of eight forms that such bad reasoning can take.

A. Petitio principii

This fallacy amounts to inferring a conclusion from premises that are, in fact, indistinguishable from the conclusion itself. This fallacy is also called circular reasoning and question begging.  Example: I know that God exists because the Bible says so. And I know that everything in the Bible is true because it is God’s word and God wouldn’t lie. 

B. Complex question

This fallacy amounts to presuming without evidence that a certain state of affairs obtains, then shaping one’s inquiry in terms of that presumption.  Example: The classic is “Have you stopped beating your wife?” but it is equally clear in “Don’t you want to be a good boy and go to bed?” 
 
C. Equivocation

 This amounts to exploiting ambiguities of words. Some are simple plays on an everyday noun or adjective. Some exploit the subtleties of dispositional and episodic participles.   Examples: When mother asks, “Were you good at the party, Susie?” Susie responds, “Well, Miles said I was.” When father asks, “Are you smoking [these days], Fred?” Fred responds, “No I’m not [right this moment].”

D. Amphibole

 This fallacy amounts to exploiting ambiguities of syntax.  Example: A subway rider explains why he lit a cigar right next to the sign that said “No Smoking Allowed” by noting the two ways that sign can be read: “Smoking is forbidden” and “Refraining from smoking is permitted.” 

E. Accent

 This fallacy amounts to exploiting ambiguities of emphasis, including selective data use.  Example: Story positioning in the media, headline writing, and small print on a box of Broccoli Rice Surprise show just what accent can do. 

F. Category mistake

 This fallacy amounts to exploiting ambiguities of classification. The term comes from Gilbert Ryle’s The Concept of Mind.  Example: Not seeing the forest for all the trees, the parade for all the marchers, and the university for all the buildings and greens are all examples of confusing things and systems. “If we have minds, then where are they?” is a more telling case in point.
    
G. Composition and division

These fallacies amount to exploiting ambiguities between the properties of individuals and the properties of the sets that they compose.  Example: “Everyone in my gymnastics class is tiny. There’s no one there over 80 pounds. I can’t see why the instructor is complaining that the class is too big.”

H. False dilemma

 This fallacy amounts to exploiting ambiguities of complementarity.  Example: “Well, Ali was certainly no hero, so he must have been a coward.”

Labels

A. S. Byatt (1) Addison (5) ADJECTIVES (2) ADVERBS (1) Aeschylus (1) Agatha Christie (1) Agora (3) American Literature (6) Ann Radcliffe (3) Anthony Powell (1) Anton Chekhov (1) APJ KALAM (1) Arianism (1) Aristotle (10) Athens (1) Avinash Jha (1) Bacon (2) Bakhtin Mikhail (3) Barthes (8) Becket (1) Ben Jonson (9) Bernard Shaw (4) BERTRAND RUSSEL (1) biography (1) Blake (1) Blogger's Corner (4) BOOK REVIEW (3) Books (3) Boswell (1) Brahman (1) Byzantium (1) CELTA (4) Charles Dickens (1) Charles Lamb (3) Charlotte Brontë (1) Chaucer (1) Coleridge (12) COMMUNICATION SKILLS (5) Confucius (1) Critical Thinking (4) Cultural Materialism (1) Daffodils (1) Deconstruction (4) Derrida (3) Doctor Faustus (5) documentary (10) Dr.Johnson (8) Drama (21) Dryden (14) E. M. Forster (1) Ecofeminism (1) Edmund Burke (1) EDWARD SAID (1) elegy (1) Emily Brontë (1) English Lit. Drama (24) English Lit. Essays (6) English Lit.Poetry (217) essays (1) Ethics (5) Evelyn Waugh (1) F.R Lewis (4) facts (1) FALLACY (1) Fanny Burney (1) Feminist criticism (10) Fielding (1) Ford Madox Ford (1) Frances Burney (3) Frantz Fanon (2) FREDRIC JAMESON (1) Freud (3) GADAMER (1) GAYATRI SPIVAK (1) General (4) GENETTE (1) GEORG LUKÁCS (1) George Eliot (1) GILLES DELEUZE (1) Gosson (1) Graham Greene (1) GRAMMAR (89) gramsci (1) Greek Mythology (17) GREENBLATT (1) HAROLD BLOOM (1) Harold Pinter (1) Hemmingway (2) Henry Fielding (1) Henry Green (1) Henry James (2) Hillis Miller (2) History (30) Holes (6) HOMI K. BHABHA (1) Hone Tuwhare (1) Horace (3) I.A.Richards (6) Ian McEwan (1) Indian linguistics (1) Indian Philosophy (8) Indian Writing in English (2) Iris Murdoch (1) Isms (3) James Joyce (1) Jane Austen (5) John Bunyan (2) John Clare (1) john Donne (1) John Osborne (1) John Rawls (1) Joseph Conrad (1) Journalism (1) Judaism (57) Kant (1) Keats (1) KERALA PSC/UPSC/BANK CLERK-PO/IFC English Grammar Exercise (85) Knut Hamsun (1) Kristeva (2) Lacan (3) Laurence Sterne (2) LINDA HUTCHEON (1) linguistics (4) linking phrases (1) linking words (1) LIONEL TRILLING (1) Literary criticism (194) literary terms (285) LOGIC (13) Longinus (4) Louis Sachar (6) LUCE IRIGARAY (1) lyric (1) Margaret Drabble (1) Marlowe (4) Martin Luther King Jr. (1) Marxist criticism (3) Mass Communication (1) Matthew Arnold (13) METAPHORS (1) MH Abram (2) Michael Drayton (1) MICHEL FOUCAULT (1) Milton (4) Modernism (1) Monroe C.Beardsley (2) Moses (1) Mulla Nasrudin Stories (224) Muses (1) MY POEMS (17) Nachmanides (1) Narratology (1) New Criticism (2) Noel Coward (1) NORTHROP FRYE (1) Norwegian Literature (1) Novel (44) O'Brien (1) Objective Types (8) Oscar Wilde (2) OSHO TALES (3) Panini (1) Parthenon (1) Pat Barker (1) PAUL DE MAN (1) PAUL RICOEUR (1) Pericles (2) Petrarch (1) PHILOSOPHY (4) PHOTOS (58) PIERRE FÉLIX GUATTARI (1) Plato (7) Poetry (24) Pope (5) Post-Colonial Reading (2) Postcolonialism (3) Postmodernism (5) poststructuralism (8) Prepositions (4) Prometheus Bound (1) Psychoanalytic criticism (4) Psychology (3) PYTHAGORAS (1) QUEER THEORY (1) Quotes-Quotes (8) Religion (1) Richardson (1) Robert Frost (7) ROMAN OSIPOVISCH JAKOBSON (1) Romantic criticism (20) Ruskin (1) SAKI (1) Salman Rushdie (1) Samuel Daniel (1) Samuel Pepys (1) Samuel Richardson (2) SANDRA GILBERT (1) SAT (2) Saussure (12) SCAM (1) Seamus Heaney (1) Shakespeare (158) Shelley (2) SHORT STORY (2) Showalter (9) Sidney (5) SIMONE DE BEAUVOIR (1) Sir Arthur Evans (1) Sir Walter Scott (3) SLAVOJ ZIZEK (1) SONNETS (159) Sophocles (1) spenser (3) St.Augustine (6) STANLEY FISH (1) structuralism (14) Sunitha Krishnan (1) Surrealism (2) SUSAN GUBAR (1) Sydney (3) T.S.Eliot (12) TED TALK (10) Tennesse Williams (1) Tennyson (1) TERRY EAGLETON (1) The Big Bang Theory (3) Thomas Gray (1) Thomas Hardy (1) Titan (1) Torah (1) tragedy (2) UGC-NET (10) Upanisads (1) Vedas (1) video (34) Virginia Woolf (2) Vocabulary test (228) W.B. Yeats (1) W.K.Wimsatt (2) WALTER BENJAMIN (1) Walter Pater (2) Willam Caxton (1) William Empson (2) William Makepeace Thackeray (2) WOLFGANG ISER (1) Wordsworth (15) writers (1) writing skill (1) Zadie Smith (1) ആത്മീയത (1) എന്‍റെ കഥകള്‍ (5) കഥ (62) കാറുകൾ (1) തത്വചിന്ത (14) ബ്ലോഗ്ഗര്‍ എഴുതുന്നു (7) ഭഗവത്‌ഗീതാ ധ്യാനം (1) മുല്ലാ നസറുദ്ദീൻ (53) സാഹിത്യ ലോകം (1)